When it works, why change it? Burt's has been making its original-formula balm in a silver-dollar-size tin for 22 years, and we're still digging it. Beeswax is the primary moisture-locking ingredient, with coconut and almond oils adding extra all-natural lube. A hint of peppermint makes the balm tingle and perks up your senses without being overpowering. [$3; burtsbees.com]