McHale admits he has always cared about his appearance – "probably stupidly so," he says – and yet he gives no credence to men who claim to rise above fashion. "If guys really didn't care, they would wear, like, a torn sport coat with an Iowa sweatshirt and a skirt," he says. "Even if you wear the same thing every day, you're still actively trying to communicate a certain look." In his case, McHale is especially fond of New York-based Isaora, a company that he says makes pieces "inspired by snowboard clothing, all very cool and fashionable." When it comes to suits, he's a fan of Calvin Klein, for style and material, but also fit – always a tall order for a very tall guy.