America’s Best Beers

Mon, Oct 5, 2009

Cover Stories, Food & Drink

America’s Best Beers
Beer! Yay, beer! Photo credit: Photograph by Nigel Cox

These 25, from New York to San Diego, represent the new standard.

by Christian DeBenedetti and Seth Fletcher

Last spring we dropped into Copenhagen’s best bar, expecting to find it stocked with Scandinavian microbrews. But a strange thing happened: Beer from Brooklyn and San Diego ruled the place. What about the beer from your continent, bartender? “We can’t sell it,” he said. “They just want to drink your stuff.” That observation guided this year’s rankings: American craft brews now dominate. As once obscure breweries such as Stone have grown into institutions, a new crop of cult favorites has emerged — Left Hand, the Bruery — along with some world-class American beer cities. Now there’s no reason to travel farther than your nearest specialty grocery store for a perfect beer.

BEST DARK BEERS
1. Ommegang Three Philosophers
A blend of two classic Belgian styles, strong dark ale and cherry lambic, this beer perfectly combines dark warming goodness and hints of chocolate, cherry, and coffee, making it the best night-hued ale on Earth.
2. Pennichuck Feuer–Wehrmann Schwarzbier
This brew is roasty, with flavors of coffee, cocoa, and hints of smoke that will make you rethink dark beers completely.
3. Oskar Blues Ten Fidy Imperial Stout
Despite coming in a can, this cinder-black espressolike 10 percent ABV elixir is great for special occasions.

BEST ALES
1. Stone Levitation Ale
It has a deep amber body, roasted-malt flavors reminiscent of the finest English ales, and the sturdy dose of hops you’d expect from a leader of the West Coast’s “extreme beer” movement. The result is the tastiest session ale we’ve had this year.
2. Lagunitas IPA
Brewed with plenty of bite (from the hops) and kick (from the 5.7 percent ABV), but not so much that your taste buds turn to leather after two pints.
3. Odell 90 Shilling Scottish Ale
This incredibly drinkable Colorado brew is great in cold weather: warming and rich but not too heavy.

BEST BELGIAN STYLE
1. Flying Fish Exit 4

This tripel (a Belgian term signifying that a massive dose of grain has been used to create the mash, the first stage in the brewing process) has an ample hop bitterness that balances the fruity, grain-given heft.
2. Southampton Grand Cru
A strong, creamy-smooth Belgian-style ale that has appealing lashes of anise, coriander, and orange peel.
3. Bruery Orchard White
From the Bruery — Orange County’s cult hit — this spicy witbier is light on the tongue and has hints of dry apple.

BEST CUTTING EDGE
1. Allagash Confluence

Belgian yeast strains, German, American, and English hops, and a transatlantic medley of grains make for a perfect evening sipper that’s earthy, tart, and winelike on the front end, warm and creamy on the back end, and delicious throughout.
2. Deschutes Dissident
Flanders-style sour brown ale bursting with tart-sweet flavors that hang in an unlikely — but near perfect — balance.
3. Dogfish Head Squall IPA
Hoppy but shockingly drink-able, thanks to the brewmaster’s dedication to balancing insane quantities of hops and malt.

BEST LAGER
1. Left Hand Polestar

Because there are no overwhelming flavors to mask mistakes, pilsners are easy to screw up. Which makes a flawless one, like this delicate brew, with its perfect carbonation and enough malt to give it real flavor, that much more impressive.
2. Victory Prima Pils
Aggressive use of German and Czech hops gives this beer a fresh, grassy aroma and a spicy bite. This is the beer geek’s barbecue brew.
3. Full Sail Session Black
Just as refreshing as the beers above; the dark hue comes from the roasting of the grains, which adds a nice smoky twist.
-

To see ten more of the best beers in the U.S., along with the craft-brew-crazy cities that make them, click here.
-
—-
-
This article originally appeared in the October 2009 issue of Men’s Journal.



, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

This post was written by:

Christian DeBenedetti - who has written 5 posts on Men’s Journal.


Send a letter to the editor

5 Comments For This Post

  1. PDX Wit Says:

    San Diego has more breweries than Portland?

    Um, no:

    http://portland.daveknows.org/2009/10/05/mens-journal-gets-its-best-beer-town-facts-wrongs-and-slights-portland/

    [Reply]

    Julie Reply:

    For one, they are comparing a city of a little over 1/2 million to a county of over 3 million… and they are probably comparing locations (i.e. SD has multiple Karl Strauss and Oggi’s) vs. actual breweries. With that said, SD still rocks for craft beer! Check out http://www.pubquest.com for every craft brewery in the U.S. and Canada.

    [Reply]

  2. Brad Says:

    Needs more Founders. Try their Red’s Rye and their Kentucky Breakfast Stout. Two of the finest beers America has to offer. I’d also add Three Floyds’ Dreadnaught IPA and Dark Lord Imperial Stout into the mix.

    Oh, and hello, Rouge Shakespeare Stout and Brutal Bitter? Damn, you guys left out a lot.

    [Reply]

  3. Frank Says:

    obviously the Great Lakes Brewing Company’s Bourbon Barrel Blackout Stout was not sampled

    [Reply]

  4. oak barrels Says:

    Which of these winners uses oak barrels in the brewing process?
    Cheers,
    Richard Weisberg

    [Reply]

  5. njaini Says:

    it is good post!

    wigs outlet

    [Reply]

11 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Twitter Trackbacks for America’s Best Beers | Men’s Journal [mensjournal.com] on Topsy.com Says:

    [...] America’s Best Beers | Men’s Journal http://www.mensjournal.com/americas-best-beers – view page – cached Last spring we dropped into Copenhagen’s best bar, expecting to find it stocked with Scandinavian microbrews. But a strange thing happened: Beer from Brooklyn and San Diego ruled the place. What… (Read more)Last spring we dropped into Copenhagen’s best bar, expecting to find it stocked with Scandinavian microbrews. But a strange thing happened: Beer from Brooklyn and San Diego ruled the place. What about the beer from your continent, bartender? “We can’t sell it,” he said. “They just want to drink your stuff.” That observation guided this year’s rankings: American craft brews now dominate. As once obscure breweries such as Stone have grown into institutions, a new crop of cult favorites has emerged — Left Hand, the Bruery — along with some world-class American beer cities. Now there’s no reason to travel farther than your nearest specialty grocery store for a perfect beer. (Read less) — From the page [...]

  2. Five Days on the Colorado Ale Trail « christian debenedetti Says:

    [...] Schilling’ which my writing partner for Men’s Journal Seth Fletcher and I placed on this year’s list of America’s best 25 beers) is in the middle of a massive expansion. After a tour of the work site, we saddled up to the bar [...]

  3. “America’s Best Beers” – Men’s Journal | BeerInBaltimore.com Says:

    [...] Interesting read.. [...]

  4. Top 5 Beer Cities & America’s Best Beers | Brookston Beer Bulletin Says:

    [...] for updates on this topic. Men’s Journal yesterday released their annual lists of beer, both America’s Best Beers and The Top Five Beer Towns in the U.S.. Let’s look at the top five cities [...]

  5. The Best Beers in America (According to Men’s Journal) « BeerJanglin’: Bloggers and Ales Says:

    [...] I wouldn’t necessarily consider them any kind of authority when listing America’s best beers, but they have a pretty solid list after all. Although in my opinion, they are overrating some [...]

  6. Jack Curtin’s LIQUID DIET » That Men’s Journal “America’s Best Beers” list. Says:

    [...] and made a bit of fun about it a couple of times of late, I think it only fair to reveal that the entire thing is now available online. Plus you can click through at the bottom of that page to their list of the Top Five Beer Cities in [...]

  7. If You Like Beer » My Midlife Manifesto Says:

    [...] ran across this article that seems worth sharing. It’s a brief rundown of America’s Best [...]

  8. Healthy Beer? Who Needs It? | MNBeer - Beer from the Twin Cities, Minnesota, Minneapolis, St. Paul and beyond Says:

    [...] of mine passed along to me some links to Men’s Health magazine wherein they discuss America’s top 25 craft beers and top 5 craft beer cities.  There’s also a another little section they do about the best [...]

  9. The Top 25 Beers in America, According to Men's Journal. Do You Agree With Their List? | KegWorks Says:

    [...] Journal ran an article on October 5th titled "America’s Best Beers" and I must admit authors Christian DeBenedetti and Seth Fletcher did a fantastic job [...]

  10. Links for 10.27.09: Chinese, cupcakes, beer, gourds « the listenerd Says:

    [...] I cannot agree with this list of the 25 best beers in America, but I can drink them. With [...]

  11. Men’s Journal Names America’s Top 25 Beers « Says:

    [...] Check out the rest of the list here [...]

Leave a Reply