Best Splurge: C.O. Bigelow My Favorite Sport Balm
Credit: Photograph by Michael Pirrocco

You'll pay a bit more for this balm, but it's worth it. Natural ingredients like coconut and olive oil, vitamin E, and beeswax soothe lips, while herbal extracts give it a nice tingle and invigorating scent. The texture is smooth, never sticky. Plus, it delivers broad-spectrum sun protection and has a carabiner attached right to the cap, for easy access outside of your pocket. [$7.50;]