Brother MFC-J4510DW
Credit: Brother International

It earns points for its unique ability to print 11x17 documents and its best-in-class print speed of 20 black-and-white pages per minute. We also liked its touchscreen and high-yield inks. But it produced decent-at-best prints, and setup was tedious. Plus, proprietary wireless-scanning software makes the process painful. [$200;]