Located down an alleyway in Elizabeth, the takeout-only Santillo's serves up one-of-a-kind pies, thanks to a legacy of pizza passion (owner Al Santillo took over from his father and grandfather) and the shop's antique brick oven, which dates back to 1904.
Powered By ZergNet
Best Places to Live
Surf Towns, Reborn Cities, and Mountain Meccas Where Life is Good
Plus: Inside Climbing's Toughest Triumph
ON NEWSSTANDS NOW
Bill Nye's Life Advice
Sign up to receive the Men’s Journal newsletter and special offers from MJ and its marketing partners.