For the most part, sports chatter does not get beyond light badinage, but there is always the risk of getting busted as a poseur and then things can suddenly turn grim. When caught red-handed for knowing nothing more than what is written on Wikipedia, the only way to save face is to back it up with cash. "Put money on the table: 'I got $100 that that really happened!'" Caton suggests. Crucially, you have to go all-in or risk losing both your rep and your wallet. "You got to make it enough money where the other guy ain't got it in his pocket either," Caton insists. "'I got $500 right fucking now that it happened in the third inning in '62!'"
Mad Men's Charming Rogue
The man who played Roger Sterling, is moving on – surfing in Montauk, hanging with his son, and directing a feature film.
Plus: Greenpeace's High-Seas Avenger
ON NEWSSTANDS NOW
What's on John Slattery's Mind
Willem Dafoe's Life Advice
Sign up to receive the Men’s Journal newsletter and special offers from MJ and its marketing partners.