Aaron Craft, Ohio State
Credit: Andy Lyons / Getty Images

He's an undersized, tenacious, hard-working, deeply faithful near-straight A student who has done mission work in Haiti. He's so square his roommates parody his 90-degree angles on Twitter. Craft would be the guy you want your sister to marry, if he wasn't already engaged. The one thing that makes him profoundly exceptional: He wins the award for America's Most Hated Player (Non-Duke Division) because he's a little scrappy fella with a penchant for breaking the heart of opponents. Never the best athlete on the floor, Craft is a spectacular leader who won't be frightened by anything coming OSU's way.