Host: Starlee Kine
It might feel like there simply aren't mysteries like there used to be, but host Starlee Kine is out to prove otherwise. Every episode sees her tackle a real-world mystery, however silly or important it may be. Her rules are simple: It can't be a mystery solvable by using the Internet. Though it's a newer show, it has already taken her to offbeat parts of the country on quests to track down the rightful owner of a belt buckle, Jake Gyllenhaal's true height, and Britney Spears herself.
Best Episode: The belt buckle adventure unfolds like a detective movie from the 1940s. It's a clear standout episode.