PB Crave Coco Bananas
Alright, alright, hear me out: this isn't traditional peanut butter, and it's kind of unfair to include something with chocolate and banana flavors, but this showed up on our doorstep and couldn't be ignored. If it had lived up to its name and been, essentially, a jar of candy, we'd have second-guessed including it here. As it is, this stuff is wonderfully subtle but undeniably delicious. This is still peanut butter, through and through, but don't try to eat it with pickles. Don't try to eat it with anything, actually — just use a spoon.
The gist: Good for a less healthy change of pace, but certainly not the dessert you might be expecting.
Price: $5 for a 16 oz. jar.