Vermont Peanut Butter Creamy
The "proprietary blend of oil roasted blanched and unblanched" nuts contained in this "super"natural peanut butter highlights the necessity for a properly roasted peanut. The lack of roasting of what seems to be a good portion of this butter's nuts kind of flattens the flavor, its pleasantly gritty texture weighed down by the fact that, should you get too greedy and take too big of a bite of this stuff at once, it tastes alarmingly like eating an entire package of peanuts at once.
The gist: A definite go-to as one part of a classic PB&J, but not distinct enough to make for a high calorie, high shame jar-by-the-spoonful midnight snack.
Price: $4.95 for a 16 oz. jar.