McSorley's (New York)
Credit: Leonard J. DeFrancisci

Before departing for the trenches of the Great War, the young patrons of this classic joint in Manhattan's East Village placed turkey wishbones on the old gaslight hanging above the bar as a prayer for good luck in the coming battles. The wishbones that still hang there today are those of the men who didn't make it back. As with so many old New York bars, this is just one enticing story dangling among many. (According to Speed, "Abraham Lincoln used to get blasted in there.") Faded photographs of Babe Ruth dot the walls. These were gifts from their photographer, who was a patron at the time of Ruth's rise to glory. Handcuffs from one of Houdini's escapes are locked to the bar top, and original John Sloan paintings, studied by countless eyes, are suspended around the room. "If you're looking for a real bar," says Speed, "that's a real bar." [McSorley's; 15 East 7th Street, New York, NY, 212-474-9148]