Clearly Lutz had his job cut out for him. He worked from the inside out. Product neglect at GM showed most noticeably in wretched interiors. Anyone who slid into the driver’s seat floated in a sea of cheap plastic assembled with all the care and precision of a four-year-old putting together an Erector set.
“Frankly, before Bob Lutz came onboard, interiors were not the priority,” admits Ed Welburn, GM’s vice-president of global design. “Often the interiors were developed in the 11th hour, and if the costs were not in alignment on the car, you would take it out of the interior. Then Bob came in with fresh eyes, talking about how bad our interiors were. We quickly reversed things.”
The exteriors were only marginally better, and Lutz made sure that changed just as fast. The curvy Pontiac Solstice two-seater earned Lutz his first big design gold star at GM. The Chevy HHR borrows liberally from the Chrysler PT Cruiser’s retro-minivan aesthetic but still turns heads (and sells well). Fans of the Cadillac CTS love its angular stance, while Saturn has transcended its plastic-bodied roots to showcase styles from GM’s European design centers.
Yet no car exemplifies the renewal of the product line better than the new Chevy Malibu, which debuted in late 2007 and vaulted GM into serious competition with Honda, Nissan, and Toyota in the all-important midsize family sedan segment. Car & Driver magazine named the four-door one of its 10 best cars of 2008.
At the same time as he overhauled the product line, Lutz set about remaking GM culture, aided by his outsider status and the recognition that the company’s future was so grim there was no reason not to follow his lead. When anyone came to Lutz saying something couldn’t be done, Lutz responded with “Says who?” Soon SEZ WHO? stickers began appearing all around the company headquarters.
Still, he can’t single-handedly raise the Titanic. The union’s refusal to make needed concessions at the bargaining table until a year ago led to GM depleting its cash resources to pay benefits and wages that far outstripped labor agreements made by foreign manufacturers, destroying profit margins. General Motors’ average U.S. labor costs are $69 per hour; Toyota’s, $48. (Unions are about the only thing Lutz won’t talk about. “It’s very sensitive,” he says.) Just as bad, GM shortchanged development of small, fuel-efficient cars for so long that it has a lot of catching up to do. While Toyota invested research money into the Prius hybrid, GM deep-sixed its EV1 electric car program and launched Hummer. It effectively ceded its role as the industry leader, pulling to the curb while Toyota sped ahead. Then came last fall’s economic collapse and December’s bailout.
If Lutz is grateful, he doesn’t show it. The congressional hearings were “a humiliating spectacle,” he says. “I hated to see three distinguished executives who are blameless put through that ordeal. I’m amazed that the financial institutions got hundreds of billions more than we did and were not put under this kind of scrutiny.” Like his fellow execs, he believes that healthcare costs and “an ever increasing tide of regulations” have burdened U.S. auto companies at the expense of foreign competition. The current troubles represent “a crisis in overall demand,” says Lutz. “Japanese sales are down just as much as ours. It’s not just raining down on dumb old Detroit.”
—-
—-
Lutz’s office at the GM tech center is like a rich kid’s bedroom in the 1950s, shelves neatly arranged with beautiful models of Ferraris, Ducatis, and Corsairs. He has a full-scale replica of a Lamborghini engine sitting in the center. On the walls, where posters of a boy’s heroes would hang, are pictures of Lutz. On his desk sits a quote etched in Lucite attributed to Italo Calvino: “Play is the mainstay of culture.”

Print this article

March 5th, 2009 at 5:46 pm
Lutz’s comments exemplify exactly what most Americans find despicable about the top-level executives managing the “Big Three” automakers. Comments such as “I hated to see three distinguished executives who are blameless put through that ordeal.” In reference to the Congressional hearings in which all three took private jets to attend. Seriously?! Those of us whose tax dollars you’re “borrowing” didn’t mismanage the automakers into financial ruin, it was their own poor designs and lack of ability to effectively manage their relationships with the unions that landed them in the positions they’re in.
And for the record, I happen to own both an ’09 Chevy Malibu and a ’00 Honda Accord. The new Malibu doesn’t hold a candle to my 9-year-old Accord with 140K miles, from both a fit and finish and a reliability perspective. Comparing Chevy to Honda is ludicrous!
[Reply]
Don Reply:
March 17th, 2009 at 11:30 am
“And for the record, I happen to own both an ‘09 Chevy Malibu and a ‘00 Honda Accord. The new Malibu doesn’t hold a candle to my 9-year-old Accord with 140K miles, from both a fit and finish and a reliability perspective. Comparing Chevy to Honda is ludicrous!”
Glad you like your 140K Mile Accord, that is a fantastic car. I am wondering how you are able to predict reliability on a vehicle no more than a few months old though? You’re crazy if you don’t like the new Malibu.
[Reply]
April 1st, 2009 at 12:39 am
General Motors is getting close to going bankrupt and to being liquidated. Ineptitude and greed of its management, its board, and its union are finally catching up with the former king of the automotive industry.
[Reply]
April 1st, 2009 at 12:41 am
What can be made of this debacle called General Motors? Will they survive or wont they? Will saving GM save Jobs?
[Reply]
June 9th, 2009 at 4:39 pm
Looks like Bob Lutz filled his helicopter with big tax payers money, fipped the stupid people holding the bag and go off into the golden sun set.
Thanks Bob… and not even a reach around!
[Reply]
June 15th, 2009 at 9:55 am
No Surprise that GM had to sink like the Titanic.. Just the pain and hard work of 300 Million Taxpayers going down the drain.. Whose responsible for that?
[Reply]
June 15th, 2009 at 10:05 am
Did Gm deserve the bailout? You Ask me I would say NO.. why? When Honda and Toyota were out inventing new cars, GM was busy boasting about its pride and Showing off its hungry hungry Daughter the Hummer
[Reply]
December 30th, 2009 at 4:04 pm
What add-on
[Reply]
January 15th, 2010 at 5:54 pm
Hello, nice blog, plenty of nice info, will return in a while to see more.
[Reply]
March 17th, 2010 at 1:54 am
Hello Readers,
I have a website which is helpful for the people across uk, and mainly situated in Banbury, so that i want to share it with all of you, please visit:
driving schools in Banbury
http://www.banbury-driving-lessons.co.uk/
A Driving schools based in Banbury supplies driving lessons from £15 by DSA approved driving instructors
[Reply]
August 15th, 2011 at 10:26 pm
yes there are beautiful! very good.
[Reply]
October 11th, 2011 at 9:41 pm
Nice post! I might finally listen to what you are saying. Overall your entire blog is great
[Reply]